Mr Douglas at the School of Arts
Brisbane Courier, Friday, 31 October 1873, p. 2.
Mr JOHN DOUGLAS, as yet the only candidate for the
representation of the electorate of Brisbane in the Legislative Assembly,
addressed a meeting of electors in the School of Arts last evening. Mr S.
Fraser presided, and about 250 persons were present, Messrs Hemmant and
Kingsford being among those on the platform.
The CHAIRMAN, in introducing the candidate, expressed his
regret at the unavoidable absence of His Worship the Mayor, who had been
prevented by indisposition from taking the chair.
Mr DOUGLAS, who was received with loud applause, commenced
by saying that as they were aware he had, some little time ago, issued a
printed address, in which he had endeavored to express his opinions on some of
the leading topics of the day. These addresses, no doubt, were generally
couched in very general terms, and the electors very properly required from all
candidates, who were about to submit themselves to their choice, some more
definite expression of their political views. Those addresses, however, might
be accepted as leading guides as to what might be expected from the more
detailed statements to be made by candidates, and in that sense he had
therefore, to some extent, prepared his hearers as to the tenor of the remarks
he proposed to make.
The electors of the colony would be shortly called upon to
give effect to the new Electoral Act which was in future to govern the
proceedings of all Parliamentary elections. He was not quite sure that the
electors, so far at any rate as their slight experience had yet gone, were very
well affected towards this Act. But it might be as well to suspend their
opinions until it was given a fair trial. He could not say that the Act
approved itself to his judgment, as it appeared to him that we had, by an elaborate
machinery ostensibly adopted with a view of guarding against personation,
perhaps committed ourselves to a very much greater evil in unwholesomely
narrowing the constituent body of the colony. (Cheers.) He did not now wish to
reflect upon the exponents or advisers of this measure; possibly they might
have been actuated by the best intentions of enlarging the political franchise,
but he was afraid the very contrary effect would prove to be the case.
He found that the electorate of Brisbane, for instance,
contained on the electoral roll 1099 names; and this he considered was a very
diminutive number to be accepted as the real representation of the manhood
suffrage of this city—for such nominally was the franchise under which
representatives were now to be elected. Yet even that small number was likely
to be still further diminished, for only yesterday by enquiring at the
Police-office, he had found that only 460 electors had applied for voters' rights.
It was true that a space of time still intervened between now and the period
appointed for the election, and it was quite possible that during this interval
considerable activity might take place in applications for voters' rights.
There were no decided indications of this, however, as yet, and he would here
strongly advise all electors whose names were on the roll to apply at once for
their "rights." Delays were dangerous, and the sooner application was
made the better.
But when we contemplated this difficulty as applied to this
city, how much more did it apply to the scattered districts. This Act was
passed on the basis of at any rate an attempted approximation to the principle
of equal electoral districts; some attempt was made to bring the different
electorates to a parity in population. But if the electoral body of Brisbane
was rendered so small, what, he asked, was likely to be the electoral body of
many outside districts? He was afraid their numbers would not exceed the
diminutive proportions which at one time attached to such electorates as the
Warrego and the Mitchell.
We had no very great right, therefore, to indulge in any
feeling of confidence in the Electoral Act under which we were soon to be
called upon to act. He had therefore been somewhat surprised to notice that the
Prime Minister had recently declared at Rockhampton that if there was one
measure more than another on which he claimed the gratitude not only of the
North but of the whole colony, it was this Act. For himself, he (Mr Douglas)
must confess that his feelings of gratitude were not of a very supereminent
character. No doubt the increase in the number of representatives was justly
demanded, and especially as regarded the Northern districts. In this sense
indeed we might be grateful to the last Parliament as setting at rest to some
extent the question of Separation.
So much for the Electoral Act; and now he was afraid he
should have to be a little egotistical, although this was not a failing which
he had hitherto very much cultivated, nor did he feel it to be one which was
very much to be admired. At the same time, he had come to the conclusion that
unless a man in his present position of a candidate gave some little prominence
to his personal views—and perhaps to his personal claims—there would be many
people who would be quite inclined to overlook them on that account.
As regarded himself, they were all aware that the field was
at any rate open when he announced himself as a candidate for the
representation of Brisbane. Besides he believed he had some claim to consider
that his previous position with regard to the electors and representative
system of the colony justified him in coming forward for the city, considering
there was a clear vacancy, with no one in the field.
Now, in conversation with many of his friends regarding his
candidature, he had been more than once met with an enquiry, which he felt
under the circumstances was a fully justifiable one, although he confessed
somewhat flattering to himself, but upon which he had been given to understand
the electors would probably require a distinct and categorical reply. Although
the question was not a usual one to put to a candidate, it had been more than
once put to himself, and he therefore wished to distinctly refer to it, and to
give at once the answer in public which he had given in private.
The question was—"Are you a candidate or likely to be a
candidate for the Speakership of the Legislative Assembly?" As he had
remarked, the question was possibly flattering to himself, but it was one which
every elector had a perfect right to ask, and he would therefore reply
positively that he was not a candidate, nor was he
likely to be so under any circumstances; nor could he
conceive that during the next Parliament was he likely, if elected, to become
connected with such an office. He felt it was necessary to say this because,
situated as the constituency of Brisbane was at present, he felt the electors
would not submit to the disfranchisement which to a great extent the acceptance
of the Speaker's chair by any of their members would involve. (Cheers.) He
wished it therefore to be distinctly understood that it was simply in the
interest of the electors that he now came forward, simply as an aspirant for a
seat in the House as member for Brisbane; and he did not consider that in the
present circumstances such membership would be consistent with their interest
if it were possible that he should accept the Speakership.
He could not but say however, that he looked upon it as a
matter of regret that any candidate should be called upon to renounce such a
position, being as it was the highest which any member of the Legislative
Assembly could attain to; but there were political necessities which must yield
to all others, and this was one of them. He did not know whether it would be
necessary to demand a similar disclaimer from his friends on the platform, and
he hoped their old friend Mr Edmondstone would also be called upon to renounce
the Speakership. (A laugh.) If this renouncement were expected from him (Mr
Douglas) as a party man, it must certainly apply to the whole party with which
he hoped to act. (Cheers.)
A similar difficulty to this had been felt in the
neighboring colonies, and in Victoria it had been proposed that after the
Speaker was elected, a writ of election should issue for his constituency, and
a new member be elected to fill his place. Whether, however, this plan would be
found practicable, he could not say, but in the meantime he thought it was very
objectionable that a good man, from his party connections, should be precluded
from accepting the office of Speaker, or that the Assembly should be precluded
from obtaining perhaps the best man for the office on this account.
He should now proceed to make a few remarks upon some of the
leading questions which Parliament would be called upon to deal with; but
before doing so, he should like to say that the relations of the members for
the city and its neighborhood towards the present or any other Government, were
of a peculiarly responsible character. There were certain questions in which
the city was materially interested, and which would have to be looked upon very
carefully. These were, he might say, business matters not necessarily connected
with politics, as for instance the improvement of the river navigation (which
he must say had been very fairly attended to by the present Government), the
question of sewage, and the very important question of the Brisbane Bridge.
His personal relations with the head of the present
Government had not been of a very pleasant or very cordial character. He could
not say that (apart from being on tolerable speaking terms) the Ministry were
either very friendly or likely to be very cordially disposed towards him; but
he wished to say that he should endeavor as far as possible, if entrusted with
the duty of guarding the interests of the electors of Brisbane, to conduct
these purely business matters on a footing apart altogether from party politics.
As regarded the bridge he considered this one of those
matters in which he should be bound to act in concert with those gentlemen who
should be elected by the constituencies of Enoggera, Wickham, South Brisbane,
and other electorates in the vicinity of the city, and he should therefore
support whatever course those gentlemen agreed upon as a line of policy to be
pursued, and he thought this would be the safest plan to adopt.
Our anxiety was to relieve the city of the excessive burden
which would attach to it if the whole of the debt which overhung the completion
of this bridge were permanently fastened on the Municipality. He thought it
must be patent to all who had watched the history of the negotiations connected
with the formation of this bridge, that the Municipality had scarcely been
fairly treated in many matters, and that it would be certainly for the
interests of the city and the whole neighborhood that the bridge should be made
free. (Cheers.)
How this was to be brought about could scarcely be said
exactly at present, but it was clear that Brisbane would have to make common
cause in this matter with the two northern towns of Maryborough and
Rockhampton, in both of which there was a desire to have bridges for the public
convenience; he presumed therefore that the enfranchisement of the Brisbane
Bridge would have to be connected with the construction of similar works at
Maryborough and Rockhampton.
He was sanguine enough to believe that the original
endowment of land at South Brisbane which had been estimated at the time at the
value of something like £50,000, might eventually be found not far from
reaching that sum if judiciously applied. Of course the very thought of
disposing of it at present would be ridiculous, but if the Government undertook
to free the bridge and make it a public work those endowments which were
connected with the original undertaking would have to revert to the Government in
part liquidation of the whole debt.
On such matters, however, he would be found quite willing to
co-operate with his brother members if he should have the good fortune to be
elected.
And now as regarded a few of the more important questions
which were likely to attract attention—and first, he would take that of
immigration, which to his mind was the most important of all. But before
proceeding he would first like to say a few words regarding the Polynesian
question.
From the first dawn of this institution amongst us he had
felt that it threatened the colony with very considerable difficulties. He
could remember the dissatisfaction he and others felt when the Polynesian Bill
was first introduced, but being ignorant as all then were of the vile practices
which had since been carried on under the system of recruiting in the Pacific
Islands, they did not of course take that strenuous objection to the bill which
they should have taken if they were aware to what it would have led.
Still, there were some of them who felt that the colony was
committing itself to a system of labor which would be fraught with evil
consequences to the country; and he had a lively recollection of having called
down upon himself a vehement denunciation from Mr Palmer, for having even in
measured terms expressed his doubt as to the wisdom of that legislation.
Everything that had since occurred had confirmed him (Mr
Douglas) in the opinion he then held, and he had never hesitated either in
England or in this colony, or under any circumstances, to express his opinion
that the people of this country as a whole had always looked upon that system
of immigration with the greatest disfavor, and he had never hesitated to say
that the practices carried on under it had been repudiated, and would continue
to be repudiated, by the vast majority of the people of the colony. (Loud
cheers.)
But so far as Polynesian emigration was concerned, he
thought they might consider it practically at an end; at all events, public
opinion had now been so clearly drawn to the vile practices, to the robbery and
wickedness which had been perpetrated under it, that the civilised nations of
the world had now got clearly to see that it must be put an end to. (Cheers.)
At least all those evils which had grown so rank were now
happily at an end, for the great maritime powers had made up their minds that
the evil should be crushed out at its source—in the islands themselves.
With regard to European immigration, remembering as he did
the unnecessary difficulties, the discourteous treatment, and, as it seemed to
him, the wilful intention, he had met with on the part of the Government at
that time, to put a stop to immigration, during the short time he was in
England, he confessed it was with some surprise, but with no less
gratification, that he now saw that the Government had fairly committed
themselves to sustain, and he hoped to increase, this valuable means of
recruiting our energies.
The present Act itself, he believed, was certainly the best
ever passed, and he would give Mr Palmer the credit that in this matter he had
taken the advice of people competent to give it. The Act was, he considered,
calculated to work most favorably, and under successful administration might be
the cause of the greatest benefit to the colony. (Cheers.)
To take one feature, alone, of the Act—in the first twelve
months after it came into operation there were upwards of 1500 applications for
remittance passages. Now he had always looked upon this form of immigration as
one of the very best, and he hoped to hear that these applications were on the
increase.
He therefore said advisedly that provided he could see this
system steadily maintained, and increased not rashly but gradually, and in
accordance with our wants, as well as also in accordance with the supply of
emigrants seeking to come out to Queensland—if, he said, he could see that this
Act were retained in force and with effective administration, he would gladly
see the present Government itself continue in power provided we could keep that
Government in check by a strong and wholesome Opposition.
He said this, not that he would commit any act in opposition
to the opinion of his political friends to keep the present Government in
power; but, being in power, it would be a source of great satisfaction to him,
whatever great differences of opinion he might have on other points with the
Government, to know that they were fairly committed to the wholesome, moderate,
and effective maintenance of this system.
There were some points however, in the administration of
this Act, which did not strike him as very satisfactory. He was not quite
satisfied that we got full value for our money; for it must be remembered that
the amount now expended on immigration was larger proportionately to the number
of immigrants we received than was ever spent before.
He should wish, however, to speak guardedly on this point,
because the present condition of things in England, of which he was unaware,
might necessitate greater relative expenditure.
But there were also certain points observable connected with
the present administration of the Immigration Act from which it would appear
that immigrants had been selected carelessly. (Cheers.)
We had seen instances recently, which he hoped were only
exceptions, but which he was sorry to say were more frequent than he liked to
see, of a character of persons arriving in some of the ships, whom it was not
desirable that we should receive into this country at all. (Loud cheers.)
He said it would be far better that we should have only half
the number of immigrants arriving than that we should have such characters as
some of those lately introduced. He hoped this would not be construed as said
in discouragement of the system, but merely as a wholesome warning of the
dangers and difficulties of an immigration policy unless very carefully
guarded. (Cheers.)
Another matter he should also like to mention while on this
subject was, that there were some people who thought we could not have too much
in the way of immigration. Now he did not agree with this opinion. He thought
the safest system of immigration was that which kept the supply well under the
demand, because the moment that the supply exceeded the demand there was a risk
of a reaction unfavorable to the whole system.
He would be therefore rather content with a moderate supply
than risk an over supply. The moment we began to see people asking for
employment and not able to get it, that moment Government
immigration—artificial immigration—began to wane.
But he thought there was no necessity for such an hour
arriving if the market were carefully watched, and the supply kept well in
connection with the demand.
He observed that the German Government had taken upon
themselves to issue an interdict upon all agents advocating emigration, and the
flow of German emigrants to America had no doubt induced this.
Now he must say he was sorry that German immigration into
Queensland was likely to be interrupted by this course, for he looked upon
Germans as some of the best immigrants that could be introduced. We never heard
of this class going to New South Wales, for they all as soon as they could,
settled upon the land, and he therefore regretted that not only from the action
of the Germans themselves, but also from the action of the Queensland
Government, German immigration was likely to be put a stop to altogether.
But he would like to remind the Government that there was a
class which were equally valuable, that could be obtained from Denmark, Sweden,
and Norway. He had recently read in the Life of Mr Brassey, a letter by that
gentleman, showing that he placed the Danish navvies only second to those of
the United Kingdom.
He would also wish to say that we might obtain a very
suitable class of men for our purposes from Northern Italy, the people of which
were also a very fine race. He hoped, therefore, that the Government would not
consider because they thought themselves shut out of the German market they
were therefore shut out from an equally good source of immigration.
As to the ships that came out, he thought it was a matter of
regret that they were all leaving the port of London, as he thought ships might
also be despatched, with very little inconvenience, from Liverpool and Glasgow
or Greenock.
Intimately connected with our immigration policy was our
policy in connection with the alienation of Crown lands, which was a question
that the new Parliament would undoubtedly be called upon to deal with, and
probably to legislate upon. Looking back upon the period during which the Crown
Lands Alienation Act of 1868 had been in force, there could be no doubt
whatever that, whatever were its faults, the alienation which had taken place
under that Act had been of the greatest benefit to the country. (Cheers.)
No doubt evils might have arisen under it, and it was more
than probable that there had been a great deal of collusive dealing in many
matters connected with it. The full scope of the Act was perhaps not seen on
its passing; but apart from that, a large amount of improvement and bona fide occupation
and residence had taken place under it; and he was quite confident that the
country had been put to very much greater use since than before it was
alienated, as could be seen by a journey through East and West Moreton.
As a whole, the working of the Act had been very successful,
although it might have been marred by deficiencies, and perhaps in some
respects by maladministration; but they all knew that the administration of the
Crown lands had proved a great difficulty even to the most experienced
Ministers.
One of the most important sub-questions in connection with
the dealing of the Crown lands which would arise during the next session would
be the question of the ten years' leases, and the more extended area which
would be now demanded for settlement. With regard to the ten years' leases and
the mode of dealing with them, he simply said that he found the last
legislation on this subject, the Homestead Areas Act, was in his opinion a
measure which was calculated to lead to further improvement and occupation.
Such being the case, if further demand arose, a similar
further extension should take place; for if the land were required, in whatever
quantity, for bona fide occupation, it must be had. (Cheers.)
He found, on consulting an excellent map at the Brisbane
Land-office that as regarded the subdivisions of runs the area we had at
present dealt with was only a fleabite in comparison with what was in reserve;
and what was in reserve should, when necessary, be boldly dealt with.
In connection with this, he would draw attention to the
powers which Parliament now had in dealing on an extended scale if they chose
with the question of the alienation of lands throughout the colony.
But before doing so he would draw attention to the pregnant
fact that the whole amount at present raised from the leasing of Crown lands in
the pastoral districts did not exceed £115,000, the estimate for 1874 being
£120,000, which he took it was a very moderate rental for the magnificent
public estate which we possessed.
He did not know that we should be called upon to raise these
rents in any way not within the four points of the Pastoral Leases Act of 1869,
as the action of the Act involved a gradual increase of these rents. But he
would point out that there was ample scope within that Act by reservation, and
by the exercise of the authority reposed under certain restrictions in the
Executive—there was ample authority, he said, to extend our sphere over the
alienation of Crown lands.
And if it were not advisable to go beyond the Act, then we
should unshrinkingly avail ourselves of the power under it to spread still
wider the benefits derived from a still further extended alienation of Crown
lands.
Clause 55 of the Pastoral Leases Act of 1869 reserved ample
power to the Executive for the time being to reserve from any run a block of
2500 acres, or to reserve any extent of land by giving six months' notice to
the lessee; and this took the effect of law, unless it was dissented to by both
Houses of Parliament.
Therefore, if it were considered necessary to extend the
alienation of Crown lands, it could be done without giving an equivalent
remuneration to the lessees for their land, as was demanded by Mr Wienholt. No
such claim could be put forward under the Pastoral Leases Act, and he should
strenuously resist anything of the kind.
And he must claim here, without any attempt at false
modesty, to lay some claim to popular support, as having taken a firm position
on this matter, for unless he had taken the steps he had done to secure this
guarantee which we now possessed in that Act, the people of the colony would
find themselves in a very much worse position than they were.
He had felt his responsibility as member of the Government
at that time, and he was determined to give effect to his opinions; if they had
not been acted upon by the Cabinet, he would certainly have left it.
Before leaving the land question, he would say that he had
never during his political career acted with the extreme squatting party, as
would be seen by referring to his votes. He did not wish to say anything hard
of that powerful, consistent, and coherent party, among whom he had had many
friends, and he would only say that he was not one of them—he had never been
one of them, and he was not likely to be one of them. (Loud cheers.)
He now came to education, and he would speak quite
distinctly and explicitly on the question, so that there could be no doubt as
to his views. The question had not in his opinion been placed in a very
alluring light at present. There had been very many changes and variations in
the pursuit of the question, so that he confessed he did not approach it as it
now stood with any very hearty feeling.
They knew that at the close of the last session an Education
Bill was introduced, and he felt himself that the occasion was an unfortunate
one to choose for the introduction of such a measure at such a time.
However, since then—after Mr Lilley's bill being brought in,
and supported by Mr Palmer—we now heard of Mr Palmer, after having necessitated
the resignation of one of his colleagues through his (Mr Palmer's) support of
that bill, going up to Rockhampton, and bringing out a new bill which he called
his own, but pronounced it a private measure, while stating his intention to
"stand or fall by it."
This of course, coming from a Minister who professed at
least to be the head of a Responsible Ministry, appeared to him (Mr Douglas)
exceedingly extraordinary; at any rate it was perfectly unusual, and he took it
to be a complete solecism in the history of legislation.
Looking at this, he said he should certainly—apart
altogether from the merits or demerits of Mr Palmer's bill—vote against it on
the second reading, and if possible on its first reading.
For his part, he thought it was better to stick by the old
rules of party warfare than by any new-fangled notions of personal
responsibility such as Mr Palmer appeared to take upon himself in this
matter—but not the responsibility of Government. (Cheers.)
His voting against the bill, however, might prove
unsuccessful, and of course under those circumstances he should go into the
merits of the bill, but his judgment refused to go into it at present.
In comparing, however, the two bills he found there were
some points on which he agreed with Mr Lilley, some on which he coincided with
Mr Palmer, and some on which he agreed with both.
In the first place, he did not like Mr Palmer's idea of
putting at the head of the Education-office a responsible Minister without a
Board.
He did not mean to say that an Education Act might not be
administered by a responsible Minister; but he utterly dissented from Mr
Palmer's axiom at Rockhampton—that he would rather have a bad responsible
Minister at the head of the Education Department than an irresponsible Board.
We know how hard it was to fix responsibility at present,
and he would ask them how would it be possible to fix the responsibility of a
bad Minister.
He did not believe, however, that there was any necessity
for an irresponsible Board, as he believed a Board could be made to a great
extent responsible and practically was responsible.
He believed that on the whole the working of the Queensland
Board had been admirable, as compared with Boards of Education in some of the
neighboring colonies (cheers); but if there were to be a change, he was not
ashamed to take an example from New South Wales, where they had now an
admirable Board of Education, under the Chairmanship of the Professor of the
University.
He observed that many candidates had expressed themselves
unfavorably towards the University clauses of Mr Lilley's bill; but apart from
the clauses as drafted he liked the general outline of the notion, and
considered it far superior to the proposal made by Mr Palmer.
He considered the idea of Common Christianity however as
impracticable, although it would be certainly very desirable, if possible to be
carried out. However, it was not practicable, and would at least receive the
strenuous opposition of a large portion of the community; and therefore he
considered it better to confine the operations of the State entirely to such
subjects as were not connected with religion or religious denominations. (Loud
cheers.)
In adopting this principle, he believed we should be only
carrying out the policy we had already distinctly adopted—the abolition of
State-aid to religion.
He was far from seeing that the teaching of purely secular
education by the State would necessarily lead to any lack of interest in
religious matters, for it could not be said there was less done in the way of
religious exposition now than before State-aid was abolished.
He had thought a great deal upon the subject, and his mind
was completely made up, so that if they elected him they must not look to him
for any further development of the system of connection between Church and
State as applied to education.
In conclusion, he must insist that they should exactly
understand his position as regarded party relations.
He did not suppose for a moment that any of them anticipated
he was going in as a Ministerial supporter. He would go into the House as he
hoped a courteous, but a decided and moderate, member of what he hoped would be
a strong and consistent Opposition. (Cheers.)
And he was quite willing to state that if such a combination
could be found amongst the Opposition members as would entitle them to believe
they could form another Government on a sound substantial and progressive
basis, he should gladly devote his best services to that party.
Mr Douglas concluded by stating that although he would not
be disappointed if he were rejected in favor of a more suitable candidate, as
he had lost most of his former love of political life, still he would do his
best to serve them faithfully and disinterestedly if they put their trust in
him.
After Mr Douglas had replied to a few questions,
Mr COOTE moved, and Mr Alderman SPENCE seconded, a vote of
confidence in Mr Douglas as the representative of North Brisbane.
The motion was put and carried unanimously.
A vote of thanks to the chairman terminated the proceedings.